The traditional approach to reading and spelling instruction began to change about 150 years ago during the Romantic era. Among other things, Romanticism emphasized imagination, creativity, and individuality. The “whole language” or “look-say” method of reading was advocated by Horace Mann, who wrote about phonics: “It is upon this emptiness, blankness, silence and death, that we compel children to fasten their eyes; the odor and fungeousness of spelling book paper; a soporific effluvium seems to emanate from the page, steeping all their faculties in lethargy.”

As Martin Cothran points out in his article, “This History of Phonics,” these ideals did not become reality in most American schools until they were picked up by John Dewey and the progressives, who implemented them in schools across America. Although John Russell Webb campaigned for the whole word method and created readers that used it in the 1850s, this method was not particularly influential until Dr. Edmund Burke Huey started to advocate for the method in 1908 and Dr. Arthur Gates at the Columbia University Teachers College published some preliminary studies on the efficacy of the whole word method in 1928. Very soon thereafter phonics became a tool to be used only when other methods of reading had failed.
Looking back, it is clear that the beginning and ongoing center of this century-long reading war has been the Teachers College of Columbia University. This “war” began in earnest with a scientific study but has turned in a different direction more recently on the basis of further scientific study. It may be tempting to despairingly say that “scientific studies” can be concocted on either side of a given debate and then to proceed to do whatever one originally thought to be the true course of action. However, as Rudolf Flesch, author of perhaps the most famous book on phonics, Why Johnny Can’t Read, points out, the early studies were limited. The experiments were not repeated multiple times before being applied more generally. The newer, “whole word” view of reading encountered resistance from people who saw that the studies violated common sense and attempted to solve a problem that didn’t exist. Furthermore, at the time, the problem was not whether students were learning to read, but only whether it was as fun or easy as perhaps it could have been. The newer studies, on the other hand, are based upon aggregate data collected over a longer period and focus specifically on the actual ability to read. In the meantime, the “whole word” method created a large population of students who couldn’t read at grade level at all.
In the beginning, the “Balanced Literacy” approach advocated by Lucy Calkins, former director of the Reading and Writing Project at the Teachers College of Columbia University (see Part I of this series), had seemed like a way to create more literacy-rich classrooms that avoided the drill of explicit phonics instruction and the boring repetition of whole-word readers (“See Spot Run. Run, Spot, Run”). Instead, Calkins emphasized sparking student curiosity, encouraging workshop learning, and promoting inquiry-based writing projects. In addition to sight words and some phonics (at least theoretically), students were taught “three cueing” (MSV) in order to help them figure out words by paying attention to meaning (M), syntax (S), and visual (V) cues. In theory, phonetic instruction was one of many strategies students were to be taught when attempting to decode, but in practice, sounding out a word phonetically was considered the last resort. In addition to downplaying phonics for early decoding, “Balanced Literacy” also attempted to teach reading comprehension without content-rich learning, reducing reading comprehension to non-content specific strategies.
While parents of children with dyslexia could see that this approach to reading was not helping their students, and while critics like E. D. Hirsch advocated for content-rich learning that didn’t reduce reading comprehension to generic skill, the Achilles’ heel of “Balanced Literacy” turned out to be a growing body of Science of Reading research. This research has made it clear that phonics should be the first and primary strategy because the centers of the brain employed in reading are those responsible for oral speech. Reading turns out not to be a “natural” process for children. Rather, explicit phonics instruction helps students connect oral speech (which is natural) to written symbols.
While the overthrow of “Balanced Literacy” is relatively recent, the scientific discoveries concerning the nature of reading have been known since at least the 1990s. As Benita Blachman wrote in her 1994 literature review of the science of reading:
We have had a scientific breakthrough in our knowledge about the development of literacy. We know a great deal about how to address reading problems—even before they begin…. The tragedy is that we are not exploiting what we know about reducing the incidence of reading failure. Specifically, the instruction currently being provided to our children does not reflect what we know from research…. Direct, systematic instruction about the alphabetic code is not routinely provided in kindergarten and first grade, in spite of the fact that at the moment this might be our most powerful weapon in the fight against illiteracy.
These new scientific discoveries align with the history of the phonetic alphabet and the history of reading instruction.
The Romantic era forgot the revolutionary nature of a simple thing like a phonetic alphabet and as a result considered it too boring for children. And the modern era has attempted to reduce learning from mastering content to mastering generic “skills.” Instead of either, perhaps we ought to cultivate a sense of gratitude that reading does really have to be that complicated. That way our next generation’s energy and resources can be directed at using reading and writing as tools for learning subject-specific content and their creative endeavors. Sometimes it is the simple and the seemingly unimpressive things … like a wheel or a lever … that make all the difference in a revolution.
Dr. Lesley-Anne Williams is a medieval scholar who teaches the great books for Memoria College. She holds a Ph.D. from the University of Notre Dame, an M.Phil. from the University of Cambridge, and a B.A. from Baylor University. Her own experience as a mom with elementary school-age children has turned her interests toward the promotion of solid literacy practices for the next generation. Her website can be found at www.lesleyannewilliams.com.