Supernatural Madness and the Danish Prince

Meliora

The scholarship on Hamlet is vast, with many essays and books exploring the intricacies and paradoxes of the Bard’s most famous play. Foremost among those paradoxes is the nature of the eponymous character’s madness. Renaissance and Victorian critics argue whether the Danish prince’s madness is true or contrived. Some claim Hamlet’s madness is merely a tool the prince uses to enact his revenge. Modern commentators have used psychoanalysis to portray Hamlet’s madness as a response to trauma. T. S. Eliot, in his own interpretation of the play, claims that Hamlet’s condition “is less than madness and more than feigned.”¹ In my own reading of the play, happily accomplished during a class at Memoria College, I was struck that Hamlet’s interaction with the Ghost of his father holds the key to understanding the nature of his madness. Hamlet exhibits (or is possessed by) some form of supernatural madness derived from his encounter with his father’s ghost. His later actions, fair and foul, result from being possessed by a supernatural presence that causes him to behave erratically.

Madness in the Greek and Christian Traditions

The idea of spiritual madness goes back to some of the earliest forms of religion and philosophy. Plato mentions it in his dialogue the Phaedrus (theia mania in Greek). Socrates says to the title character,

For if it were a simple fact that insanity is an evil, the saying would be true; but in reality the greatest of blessings come to us through madness, when it is sent as a gift of the gods. For the prophetess at Delphi and the priestesses at Dodona when they have been mad have conferred many splendid benefits upon Greece.²

According to Plato, madness confers insight and benefit upon those who receive it. Plato also explains that there are other types of positive madness, such as the madness of poets and lovers. A less favorable instance of madness in Greek antiquity appeared in the Dionysian cults with the bloodthirsty Maenads portrayed in Euripides’ version of the Bacchae. Theia mania, while not central to Greek religious experience, was well enough known for Plato, Euripides, and others to comment on it.

Religious madness also appears in early Christianity. Scholar Dennis MacDonald says,

As with Dionysius’s Maenads, early Christians cherished divine madness: glossolalia, speaking in the “tongues of angels.” Worshippers became ecstatic and uttered incomprehensible sounds, “mysteries,” that other worshippers translated into meaningful exhortations, prophecies, prayers, songs, or blessings.³

According to MacDonald, there is a clear connection between Greek notions and Christian conceptions of religious madness. It is also noted there are clear similarities between the Prophet Tiresias’ defense of the Maenads’ drunken prophecy in the Bacchae and the Book of Acts’ defense of speaking in tongues: “Acts attempts to defend the Spirit-led speaking in tongues within the early church, that while it sounds like drunken, unintelligible glossolalia to outsiders, it is actually intelligible prophecy.”⁴ While there are significant similarities between theia mania and Christian notions of madness, these conceptions of madness also have some differences. Namely, Greek madness involves a type of possession that expels the possessee’s consciousness, while with Christian glossolalia the individual is never completely expelled but has his mind united with the Spirit in divine ecstasy. Also, the will and reason are both subsumed by the mystical being in the Greek conception, but in the Christian tradition, the will is never wholly subsumed. Free will remains inviolate. Reason remains but is overshadowed and joined to the Spirit. Christianity takes the madness of the Greek world and “imitates the Bacchae because of its popularity and similarity with Christian teaching, while still retaining a focus on rationality.”⁵ So, Christianity adapts this form of madness to fit with the more rational nature of Christianity.

St. Paul, however, speaks negatively about too much madness within a Christian community, and later mainstream Christian traditions deemphasize glossolalia and other types of “madness.” But such religious ecstasy never disappears completely from the Christian tradition. There were forms of Christian madness in several different Christian and heretical sects, such as the Paulicians in the seventh century, the Bogomils in the tenth century, and the Cathars in the twelfth, just to name a few. It could even be said that Catherine of Siena’s more orthodox mysticism was a form of madness. But it was not until the Protestant Reformation that the tradition reappeared in a more mainstream way. For example, radical reformers such as the Anabaptists and the Moravians taught that “the advent of the Spirit evoked prophecy, which conveyed prescriptions for Christian living and new eschatological understandings.”⁶ Thus, such madness existed in somewhat limited form throughout the history of Christianity but started to grow more popular with the Protestant Reformation—that is, in Shakespeare’s time.

Historical Connections to Hamlet

An interesting yet overlooked connection between these ideas and Hamlet appears in the person and ideas of Martin Luther’s teacher, Andreas Bodenstein von Karlstadt. Karlstadt and Luther were allies and friends as the Reformation began. Later, they fell out over issues such as iconoclasm, infant baptism, and the nature of efficacious grace in the Eucharist. Karlstadt was famous for his erratic and eccentric behavior and for his interest in the mystical teachings of the German mystic Johann Tauler.⁷ One dispute between Karlstadt and Luther was the former’s insistence that the Holy Spirit had spoken directly to him. Lutheran scholar Russell Dawn says that Karlstadt

did not lean on God’s word but asserted instead that the Holy Spirit had spoken to him inwardly, instructing him in his own spirit. Further, von Karlstadt’s followers could experience the same inward voice of the Spirit.⁸

Dawn goes on to say that Luther himself maintained in his tract Against the Heavenly Prophets in the Matter of Images and the Sacraments that Karlstadt instructed his followers to find “some imaginary realm” where “a heavenly voice will come, and God himself will speak to you.”⁹ Now, whether that heavenly voice was the Holy Spirit or some sinister voice seducing Karlstadt into sin is unclear. Either way, taking him at his word, some spirit (good or evil) inspired him to preach and act in specific ways. His mysticism was thus akin to supernatural madness, and his behavior, as others described it, was strange, verging on madness. Perhaps his erratic behavior came from the supernatural or from his conception of it. He certainly believed his words and actions were divinely inspired, which, as noted in the examples above, can lead to a form of madness. His story demonstrates that the supernatural (or a perception of it) can reveal itself to a person who consequently becomes erratic and that this idea was in vogue in some Reformation circles. Moreover, there is a connection between Karlstadt and Hamlet. Karlstadt was the chair of the theology department and later chancellor of the University of Wittenberg, the same university Shakespeare’s Hamlet attends before returning to Denmark.

Some scholars, including Memoria College’s own Joseph Pearce, have described Hamlet as having distinctive Protestant ideas about faith and philosophy as opposed to his father’s more Catholic sensibilities. Pearce says, “If Hamlet appears to be a Protestant of sorts, it is curious that the Ghost of his father is indubitably Catholic.”¹⁰ Hamlet could well have returned home with more of a Protestant mindset through exposure to the new ideas of the Reformation thinkers, including those of Luther, Melanchthon, and Karlstadt. It is reasonable to suppose that Hamlet could have learned of Karlstadt’s view that the Spirit (or spirits) could speak directly to men and push them toward specific actions. There is no clear evidence that Karlstadt’s ideas directly influenced Shakespeare or Hamlet. However, it remains plausible that Shakespeare situated Hamlet at a particular place, Wittenberg, where he could have been exposed to notions of religious madness. Thus, there appears a direct link between Hamlet and the resurfacing ideas of direct human inspiration by supernatural forces.

Now that we have established some context about supernatural madness and its connection to Hamlet, it would be helpful to have a definition of the term for our analysis of Hamlet. Pulling from the historical discussion above, supernatural madness is the direct intervention of a supernatural other (God, spirit, or ghost) into the affairs of a human person, causing him to follow a path that fulfills the will of the otherworldly being. Again, our purpose is to show how this supernatural madness influences Hamlet and explains his actions, not to endorse or condemn the morality of such actions. So let us now turn to Hamlet, the play.

Supernatural Madness in Hamlet

Hamlet’s madness does not come all at once but rather gradually increases after his otherworldly encounter with the Ghost. Several other scenes also shed light on how his madness presents in the play. The first scene is a foreshadowing moment between Hamlet and his friend Horatio, as Hamlet sees the Ghost for the first time. In Act I, scene IV, Hamlet tells Horatio, upon seeing the Ghost, “It will not speak; then I will follow it.” Horatio responds, “Do not, my lord.” But Hamlet is insistent: “Why, what should be the fear? / I do not set my life at a pin’s fee; / And for my soul, what can it do to that, / Being a thing immortal as itself?” Hamlet, in his hubris, sees his soul, being immortal, as being on the same plane as the Specter with which he desperately wishes to speak.

But his friend knows better, for he responds to Hamlet,

What if it tempt you toward the flood, my lord?
Or to the dreadful summit of the cliff
That beetles o’er his base into the sea,
And there assume some other horrible form,
Which might deprive your sovereignty of reason
And draw you into madness?

Horatio correctly predicts, although he does not know precisely how, that the encounter between Hamlet and his father’s ghost will result in Hamlet being deprived of his reason. This exchange of words happens just before Hamlet leaves to speak with the Ghost, so the play puts the reader on guard for potential madness induced by a close encounter with the apparition. Shakespeare is too gifted to have used such a conversation as a throwaway. Rather, the playwright tells his readers that a form of supernatural madness is a possibility for Hamlet and could have dire consequences.

Next, the supernatural enters into the play. Hamlet speaks to the Ghost, his father, the deceased king of Denmark. This scene is critical for our argument. After the Ghost appears, but before he reveals his identity and purpose, Hamlet foolishly urges the specter, “Speak; I am bound to hear.” Hamlet assents to hear all the Ghost has to say and even binds himself to the being’s words. The Ghost appears and says, “So art thou to revenge, when thou shalt hear.” Hamlet has opened himself up to the supernatural by agreeing to hear the Ghost. Thus open, he has no choice but to hear and to accept what the creature says, “I am thy father’s spirit … If thou didst ever thy dear father love—… Revenge his foul and most unnatural murder.” Hamlet, moved by passion upon hearing what the Ghost says, immediately agrees to enact the Ghost’s revenge, saying, “Haste me to know’t, that I, with wings as swift / As meditation or the thoughts of love, / May sweep to my revenge.”

The Ghost reveals that Hamlet’s uncle, Claudius, was his murderer. Hamlet responds in a way reminiscent of an oracle receiving a vision from a god or a newly awakened Protestant receiving direct inspiration from the Spirit: “O my prophetic soul! My uncle!” This line seems to be the start of a prophetic trance, as the Ghost goes on to tell Hamlet how his brother poisoned him and married his widow, Queen Gertrude, making the royal bed a place of lust and incest. As the Ghost exits, Hamlet, overwhelmed by madness, says,

I’ll wipe away all trivial fond records,
All saws of books, all forms, all pressures past,
That youth and observation copied there,
And thy commandment all alone shall live
Within the book and volume of my brain,
Unmix’d with baser matter. Yes, by heaven!
O most pernicious woman!
O villain, villain, smiling, damned villain!

Hamlet is thrown into deep shock by what he has seen. His soliloquy shows us the depth of his emotion. In it, we can see madness take root in Hamlet. He will “wipe away all trivial fond records, / All saws of books, all forms, all pressures past, / That youth and observation copied there.” He is, in effect, wiping away all that has made him human. All his past learning and knowledge must be swept aside because of the Ghost’s “commandment all alone shall live / Within the book and volume of my brain, / Unmix’d with baser matter.” Hamlet’s response is like that of a prophet who has heard his god speak directly to him. His mind no longer wishes to contain any base human knowledge but must be devoted to the Ghost’s task.

This loss of ordinary knowledge then appears in Hamlet’s scenes with Polonius, where Hamlet completely forgets who Polonius is, even though he has been a longtime advisor to his father and is the father of his love interest, Ophelia. His madness is also eerily similar to the above-mentioned examples, such as the Oracle at Delphi or early Christian glossolalia. Thus, if Hamlet believes that the Ghost has given him a mandate, he has no option but to pursue his quest for revenge, even if it destroys his family, friends, and himself. All else must be put to the side so that this supernatural madness that has taken hold of him might achieve his father’s revenge.

We see this strangeness confirmed at the end of Hamlet’s speech. After the Ghost speaks of prophecy and revenge, Marcellus and Horatio finally catch up with Hamlet. They opine to the prince about the words of the Ghost. Hamlet, in a mocking tone, says to them, “Hillo, ho, ho, boy! Come, bird, come!” And then speaks an obvious truth, “There’s never a villain dwelling in all Denmark / But he’s an arrant knave.” Horatio responds reasonably to Hamlet’s bizarre talk: “These are but wild and whirling words, my lord.” Later on, as Hamlet attempts to swear them to secrecy upon his sword, even though these men are sworn to him already, Horatio says again, “O day and night, but this is wondrous strange.” Hamlet’s first human interaction after the Ghost’s revelation is markedly different from his usual way of acting. So, for Horatio, who also attended the University of Wittenberg and is friends with Hamlet, Hamlet’s actions and mental state provide clues that Hamlet’s experience with the Ghost was no mere hallucination. Rather, Horatio’s statements help us to realize that the Ghost’s directive for revenge has begun to consume Hamlet’s mind and lead him down a path of pain, destruction, and madness.

While there are many examples of madness throughout the play, we will focus on two additional examples that help demonstrate the type of madness that possesses Hamlet. In Act III, scene IV of the play, Hamlet accuses his mother, Queen Gertrude, of helping to kill his father. Then, he kills the old advisor, Polonius, stabbing him through a screen. The Queen, shocked at Hamlet’s accusations and the murder of Polonius, exclaims: “What have I done that thou dar’st wag thy tongue / In noise so rude against me?” But Hamlet repeats his accusation and further says,

Sense, sure, you have,
Else could you not have motion; but sure that sense
Is apoplex’d; for madness would not err,
Nor sense to ecstasy was ne’er so thrall’d
But it reserv’d some quantity of choice
To serve in such a difference.

The quotation is buried in the middle of a longer monologue, but it is telling in revealing the nature of Hamlet’s madness. He claims that even madness has a type of sense or reason to it. This madness seems to have purpose to it, or else he “would not err.” His mother’s actions, or so he claims, are the real insanity, as her madness is entirely unreasonable and lacks purpose. Hamlet’s actions, on the other hand, are more calculated and directed at a specific purpose. Just a few lines after this conversation with the Queen, the Ghost reappears to Hamlet, urging him to refocus on his true work of killing his uncle instead of harassing his mother. These words further demonstrate that Hamlet’s madness is no ordinary insanity but something greater, a holy quest. This scene develops the contrast between Hamlet’s madness and the more common form of madness that his mother possesses. More importantly, the new ghostly announcement introduces the concept of strategic or calculated action within Hamlet’s madness, which is critical to understanding how supernatural madness differs from regular insanity.

To understand the idea of calculation within madness more fully, we shall return to a discussion of the history of religious madness for a moment. Certain themes and ideas within different cultures or traditions find surprising similarities in other traditions and cultures, even with little direct historical connection. The madness practiced by certain yogis in the Tibetan school of Buddhism, for example, bare a striking resemblance to our discussion of Hamlet’s madness even though there is certainly no direct historical link between the two. According to scholar David DiValerio, within Tibetan Buddhism, there is a tradition of “madmen” whose “‘madness’ carries a positive valuation more often than a negative one.”¹¹ DiValerio says further that this madness can even be seen as a “strategic, purposeful activity,”¹² and that “the ‘holy madman’ tradition is constituted by highly self-aware individuals making strategic use of the theme of madness in the construction of their public personas.”¹³ It seems that Hamlet is doing something similar in the play. Since we have already suggested that Hamlet’s madness is not feigned, Hamlet must be somehow mad and yet simultaneously sane enough to act strategically. The fact that Hamlet occasionally seems reasonable and free from his madness does not prove that Hamlet is merely acting. Rather, it reinforces the assertion that Hamlet is possessed by a supernatural madness that allows him to be calculating. This demonstrates that Hamlet is indeed possessed of madness of an unnatural sort, as it helps to resolve the apparent contradictions that so many, like Eliot, have pointed out.

To summarize, Hamlet’s madness seems to be historically plausible. It is triggered by his interaction with the Ghost, causing him to act in strange and eccentric ways, which is confirmed by a close confidant in Horatio. Furthermore, Hamlet still has the ability to act reasonably when it is demanded of him in pursuit of his goal, yet he is still mad, which is consistent with some forms of religious madness.

With this understanding, let us turn to the moment that Hamlet achieves the goal the Ghost set before him: avenging his father’s death by killing Claudius. In the final scene of the play, Act V, scene II, we see Hamlet summoned to the king’s presence, and King Claudius attempts to reconcile him to Laertes, who is all too aware that Hamlet killed his father, Polonius. Hamlet says to Laertes:

What I have done
That might your nature, honour, and exception,
Roughly awake, I here proclaim was madness.
Was’t Hamlet wrong’d Laertes? Never Hamlet.
If Hamlet from himself be ta’en away,
And when he’s not himself does wrong Laertes,
Then Hamlet does it not, Hamlet denies it.
Who does it, then? His madness. If ‘t be so,
Hamlet is of the faction that is wrong’d;
His madness is poor Hamlet’s enemy.
Sir, in this audience,
Let my disclaiming from a purpos’d evil
Free me so far in your most generous thoughts
That I have shot my arrow o’er the house
And hurt my brother.

While it may seem that Hamlet is speaking facetiously and trying to antagonize Laertes, sometimes the best way to read a passage is at face value. If we take Hamlet’s words here as he says them, Hamlet says his madness is responsible for the killing of Polonius and, subsequently, for killing Laertes and Claudius. In this passage, he finally realizes that his reason has been usurped by that of the Ghost (just as Horatio warned him) and that the madness guiding him throughout the play is not his own but that of a supernatural other. But this realization is too late for Hamlet to turn aside from the Ghost’s purpose, and he is driven to exchange blows with Laertes, who wounds him with a poisoned rapier (as Claudius had convinced Laertes to kill Hamlet). In their scuffle, Hamlet disarms Laertes and wounds him in turn, then forces Claudius to drink poison, killing him: “Here, thou incestuous, murd’rous, damned Dane, / Drink off this potion. Is thy union here?” Directly after Claudius’ death, Laertes seemingly comes to his own realization, confirming that Hamlet, the man, is not responsible for his or his father’s deaths:

He is justly serv’d:
It is a poison temper’d by himself.
Exchange forgiveness with me, noble Hamlet.
Mine and my father’s death come not upon thee,
Nor thine on me!

Laertes seems to be confirming what was said above, namely that Hamlet is not responsible for his or Polonius’ death. Rather, it was another’s will which forced them to clash. In Laertes’ case, it was the will of Claudius attempting to use Laertes to rid himself of his troublesome nephew. If it was not Hamlet’s will that forced their clash, then the only other option is that the will of the Ghost, through supernatural madness, drove Hamlet to take such drastic action to carry out its revenge. Thus, the end of the play again displays that Hamlet’s madness is best understood through the lens of a supernatural madness, and this in turn helps us understand the paradox of Hamlet’s madness evidenced throughout the play.

Possible Objections

But before we conclude, let us consider counterarguments to our claim that Hamlet was possessed by divine madness—for no real argument is complete without at least considering possible objections. There are two main arguments that could be made against our thesis. First, Hamlet is merely acting the part to seek his revenge, and his madness is entirely feigned. Second, Hamlet’s madness is altogether of a psychological nature, stemming solely from some type of psychotic break. While there are many other arguments that we might discuss, we will focus our attention on just these two.

There is a legitimate argument to be made that Hamlet is putting on an act so that he might more easily investigate the claims of the Ghost that Claudius murdered his father. Let us consider Act I, scene V; just after the section where we left off with Horatio commenting on how strange Hamlet seems to be acting, Hamlet tells Horatio:

Here, as before, never, so help you mercy,
How strange or odd some’er I bear myself—
As I perchance hereafter shall think meet
To put an antic disposition on—
That you, at such times seeing me, never shall,
With arms encumb’red thus, or this head-shake, …
That you know aught of me—this do swear,
So grace and mercy at your most need help you.

Hamlet tells Horatio that he plans to put on an “antic disposition” to seem mad, but Horatio must not give him away with even the slightest head-shake. No matter how strange Hamlet acts, Horatio must stay true to his oath not to betray what Hamlet has confided in him concerning his father’s murder. Thus, Hamlet’s madness seems just an act, as he himself tells his friends (and the audience) that he is putting on a show.

On the other hand, we have the luxury of seeing Hamlet’s actions throughout the play, not merely in this closing scene of Act I. There are still four acts and over thirty-two hundred lines of poetry left for Hamlet to prove his madness. And prove it he does as demonstrated by the arguments we have previously made. First, his madness is foreshadowed before he even meets the Ghost, implying that he will go mad if he speaks with the Ghost, which should incline us to think his actions might make him actually mad. He also starts acting strangely, as he is already under the influence of the Ghost before he tells Horatio he is acting. Hamlet is practicing the Tibetan-style madness of someone who is influenced by supernatural madness but can still act in a calculating manner. Add to this all the other examples of Hamlet’s behavior that are constantly described as mad. Thus, Hamlet’s actions cannot really be just an act, even if he thought they were. His actions clearly indicate someone who has some spark of the mad about him.

On the other hand, there are also several interesting arguments that Hamlet is completely mad due to a mental break, but I ultimately think it wrong to categorize Hamlet’s madness as a true psychotic break, as he does not fully manifest the symptoms of such an intense collapse of his mental state. Rather, his breakdown could more accurately be described as a neurotic depression. While neurosis can be powerful and lead to an erratic mental state, it is not as dramatic a break, say, as King Lear, who seems to meet the conditions of true psychosis more readily. Hamlet’s neuroticism is on full display throughout the play. In Act II, scene II, Hamlet laments the condition of his life in a depressing soliloquy, “O, what a rogue and peasant slave am I!” And “I, / A dull and muddy-mettl’d rascal.” And later on, in the same speech, “I am pigeon-livered” and “What an ass am I!” or earlier in the play, before he even meets the Ghost, he says:

O, that this too too solid flesh would melt,
Thaw, and resolve itself into a dew!
Or that the Everlasting had not fix’d
His canon ‘gainst self-slaughter! O God! God!
How weary, stale, flat, and unprofitable,
Seem to me all the uses of this world!

These quotations show us a mind that is wracked with neurotic doubt. Hamlet is disgusted with himself because he does not have the courage to avenge his father. While he does work up the courage to test his uncle to see if he truly knows about his father’s murder, this mustering only deepens the turmoil in his soul as he struggles to balance the death of his father and his mother’s marrying the murderer. His intensifying neurosis causes him to act madly throughout the play, as he cannot escape his troubled thoughts and so lashes out to quiet them. Thus, mental anguish, not psychosis, is the real cause of Hamlet’s madness.

While there is some truth to this argument, as Hamlet does struggle with some form of acute mental distress, this approach ignores the supernatural element in the play. A ghost really does appear to Hamlet and tells him that his uncle murdered his father. The Ghost is seen by several other individuals, who all confirm its existence. Most importantly, the claims of the Ghost turn out to be entirely true. Hamlet’s uncle really did kill his father, providing Hamlet with information he would not have known otherwise, causing his spiral into supernatural madness. So, Hamlet is not merely acting as a madman because he is depressed. He acts mad because a supernatural being speaks directly to him, giving him a supernatural undertaking to enact its revenge. Hamlet might very well exhibit neurotic behavior, which might add to his appearance of insanity, but I believe, due to the evidence presented, that to portray his madness as merely mental illness does a disservice to a crucial element of the play. The argument for neurosis-caused madness in the play is much better made for the character Ophelia, as her madness is much more typically neurotic and ultimately suicidal.

Conclusion

Returning to Eliot’s line, which helped us to frame our discussion, we find that Hamlet’s condition is more than feigned but also more than madness as well. It is more than madness because it is not ordinary madness that he possesses; it is a supernaturally inspired madness. Thus, we can make sense of the seemingly contradictory nature of Hamlet’s character and gain a greater understanding of the play. Hamlet’s words and actions are not paradoxical; rather, they are united so that the will of an otherworldly spirit might be accomplished through him.

Notes

  1. T. S. Eliot, “Hamlet and His Problems,” in Selected Essays (New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich, 1950), 183.
  2. Translation by Harold N. Fowler (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1925), 244a–244b.
  3. Dennis MacDonald, “Classical Greek Poetry and the Acts of the Apostles: Imitations of Euripides’ Bacchae,” in Christian Origins and Greco-Roman Culture, eds. Stanley E. Porter and Andrew W. Pitts (Leiden: Brill, 2013), 467.
  4. Ilseo Park, “Acts 2 as an Intertextual Map: Moving from Dionysian to Platonic Identity,” in Classical Greek Models of the Gospels and Acts: Studies in Mimesis Criticism, eds. Mark G. Bilby, Michael Kochenash, and Margaret Froelich (Claremont, CA: Claremont Press, 2018), 118.
  5. Ibid., 121.
  6. Stanley Burgess, “Evidence of the Spirit: The Medieval and Modern Western Churches,” in Initial Evidence: Historical and Biblical Perspectives on the Pentecostal Doctrine of Spirit Baptism, ed. Gary B. McGee (Peabody, MA: Hendrikson Publishers, 1991), 28.
  7. Encyclopedia Britannica, “Andreas Karlstadt.”
  8. Russell Dawn, “Martin Luther on the Holy Spirit: A Lesson in Sticking to the Basics,” Modern Reformation 24, no. 2 (2015).
  9. Ibid.
  10. William Shakespeare, Hamlet, ed. Joseph Pearce (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2008), xiv. All quotations of the play are from this edition.
  11. David Michael DiValerio, “Subversive Sainthood and Tantric Fundamentalism: An Historical Study of Tibet’s Holy Madmen,” PhD Dissertation, University of Virginia, 2011, ii.
  12. Ibid., ii.
  13. Ibid., iii.
Skip to content